The Historic Flanagan-Kincaid House
The Historic Flanagan-Kincaide House Fishers IN was built by the Flanagan family sometime before 1865. Located at 10908 USA Pkwy, Fishers, IN 46037. Its architecture fits in nicely with the period between 1853 and 1865. Peter Flanagan died intestate, and John B. died without leaving a will. The Flanagans’ daughter, Sarah C., died between 1871 and 1901. Ingram Flanagan’s wife, Sarah, died after 1871. The Flanagans’ children inherited the property until the Kincaid family bought it in 1937. The house was then owned by the Kincaid family until recently.
The Flanagan-Kincaid House is a beautifully restored Italianate-style farmhouse. The Flanagan family built the house in 1861 and made clay bricks on-site. The Kincaid Family later owned the house and founded the L.E. Kincaid Meat Market. The Flanagan-Kincaid House has been restored by the Thompson Thrift Company and Hamilton County Tourism to help it stay open to the public.
The Morris-Flanagan-Kincaid House was scheduled to be demolished four years ago. It was saved from demolition and will be moved to a new location on the USA Parkway near Ikea and Portillo’s. The building is slated to move to its new location by December. In the meantime, it will serve as a centerpiece for a new roundabout, and the city hopes to complete the roundabout around it.
The Kincaid-Kincaid House has been a symbol of the rich history of Fishers. Originally built by the Flanagan family, the home was rescued by local preservation groups. The property sits near a future exit ramp and office park. Despite its location in a busy suburb, the Kincaid-Kincaid House has been saved from demolition.
While the house is on Navient’s campus, it will be moved less than a mile away to its new home. The nonprofit group Noblesville Preservation Alliance, which was founded in 2014, raised funds to move the house and donate the property. Navient agreed to donate the 2 acres on its campus for the house. The organization also has a plan to create a new exhibit area to tell the story of the house.
Fortunately, the new location for the house is just northwest of the roundabout. This location will include a viewing area, which will be accessible via a sidewalk to the north. The entire process is similar to loading a semi and moving the home, except it is smaller and easier to move. Ultimately, though, the house will still need some work, since there is no floor and no plumbing.